很精典的文章，可以回答很多刚开始学习游戏制作的兄弟姐妹的问题！

[此贴子已经被作者于2004-05-17 20:57:36编辑过]

感谢提供给大家！

我看不到文件呀，给我发　yanqiang1224@163.com

原 文：What Language Do I Use 　　译 者：Sunlxy 　　版 本：the first edition（Ver 1.0） --------------------------------------------------------------------------------

　　这是每个游戏编程FAQ里都有的问题。这个问题每星期都会在游戏开发论坛上被问上好几次。这是个很好的

问题，但是，没人能给出简单的答案。在某些应用程序中，总有一些计算机语言优于其他语言。下面是几种用

于编写游戏的主要编程语言的介绍及其优缺点。希望这篇文章能帮助你做出决定。 　　This is a question that belongs in every game programming FAQ. It seems to be asked in a game

development forum several times a week. It's a good question, though, and not one with an easy

answer. There are computer languages that work better for some applications than others. Here is

a list of the major programming languages used to write games along with descriptions,

advantages, and disadvantages. Hopefully this list will help you make a decision.

1、C语言 　　如果说FORTRAN和COBOL是第一代高级编译语言，那么C语言就是它们的孙子辈。C语言是Dennis Ritchie在

七十年代创建的，它功能更强大且与ALGOL保持更连续的继承性，而ALGOL则是COBOL和FORTRAN的结构化继承者

。C语言被设计成一个比它的前辈更精巧、更简单的版本，它适于编写系统级的程序，比如操作系统。在此之前

，操作系统是使用汇编语言编写的，而且不可移植。C语言是第一个使得系统级代码移植成为可能的编程语言。 　　If FORTRAN and COBOL were the first compiled high-level languages, then C is their

grandchild. It was created in the 70's by Dennis Ritchie as a tighter and more coherent successor

to ALGOL, which was a structured successor to COBOL and FORTRAN. It was designed to be a smaller

and simpler version of its predecessors, suitable for writing system-level programs, like

operating systems. Before then, operating systems were hand-coded in assembly and were not

portable. C was the first programming language that made portability a reality for system-level

code.

　　C语言支持结构化编程，也就是说C的程序被编写成一些分离的函数呼叫（调用）的集合，这些呼叫是自上

而下运行，而不像一个单独的集成块的代码使用GOTO语句控制流程。因此，C程序比起集成性的FORTRAN及COBOL

的“空心粉式代码”代码要简单得多。事实上，C仍然具有GOTO语句，不过它的功能被限制了，仅当结构化方案

非常复杂时才建议使用。 　　C is a language that supports structured programming. That is to say that C programs are

written as collections of disconnected function calls that run top-down rather than a single

monolithic block of code with program control-flow happening via GOTO statements. Hence, C

programs are generally easier to follow than monolithic FORTRAN and COBOL spaghetti-code.

Actually, C still has a GOTO statement, but its functionality is limited and it is only

recommended as a last resort if structured solutions are much more complicated.

　　正由于它的系统编程根源，将C和汇编语言进行结合是相当容易的。函数调用接口非常简单，而且汇编语言

指令还能内嵌到C代码中，所以，不需要连接独立的汇编模块。 　　True to its system-programming roots, it is fairly easy to interface C with assembly

languages. The function-calling interface is very simple, and assembly language instructions can

be embedded within C code, so linking in separate assembly-language modules is not necessary.

　　优点：有益于编写小而快的程序。很容易与汇编语言结合。具有很高的标准化，因此其他平台上的各版本

非常相似。 　　Advantages: Good for writing small fast programs. Easy to interface with assembly language.

Very standardized, so versions on other platforms are similar.

　　缺点：不容易支持面向对象技术。语法有时会非常难以理解，并造成滥用。 　　Disadvantages: Does not easily support object-oriented techniques. Syntax can be difficult

and lends itself to abuse.

　　移植性：C语言的核心以及ANSI函数调用都具有移植性，但仅限于流程控制、内存管理和简单的文件处理。

其他的东西都跟平台有关。比如说，为Windows和Mac开发可移植的程序，用户界面部分就需要用到与系统相关

的函数调用。这一般意味着你必须写两次用户界面代码，不过还好有一些库可以减轻工作量。 　　Portability: While the core of the language and the ANSI function calls are very portable,

they are limited to control-flow, memory management, and simple file-handling. Everything else is

platform-specific. Making a program that's portable between Windows and the Mac, for instance,

requires that the user-interface portions be using system-specific function calls. This generally

means that you need to write the user-interface code twice. There are libraries, though, that

make the process a bit easier.

　　用C语言编写的游戏：非常非常多。 　　Games Written in C: Lots and lots.

　　资料：C语言的经典著作是《The C Programming Language》，它经过多次修改，已经扩展到最初的三倍大

，但它仍然是介绍C的优秀书本。一本极好的教程是《The Waite Group's C Primer Plus》。 　　Resources: The classic book about C is [The C Programming Language].It's gone through several

iterations and has expanded to about three times its original size, but it's still a good

introduction to the language. An excellent tutorial is [The Waite Group's C Primer Plus].

2、C++ 　　C++语言是具有面向对象特性的C语言的继承者。面向对象编程，或称OOP是结构化编程的下一步。OO程序由

对象组成，其中的对象是数据和函数离散集合。有许多可用的对象库存在，这使得编程简单得只需要将一些程

序“建筑材料”堆在一起（至少理论上是这样）。比如说，有很多的GUI和数据库的库实现为对象的集合。 　　C++ is the object-oriented successor to C. Object-oriented, or OO, programs are the next step

beyond structured programming. OO programs are built out of objects, which are packages of data

and functions collected into discrete units. There are many libraries of objects available that

make writing programs as simple as pulling together a collection of program "building blocks" (at

least in theory). For example, there are many GUI and database libraries that are implemented as

collections of objects.

　　C++总是辩论的主题，尤其是在游戏开发论坛里。有几项C++的功能，比如虚拟函数，为函数呼叫的决策制

定增加了一个额外层次，批评家很快指出C++程序将变得比相同功能的C程序来得大和慢。C++的拥护者则认为，

用C写出与虚拟函数等价的代码同样会增加开支。这将是一个还在进行，而且不可能很快得出结论的争论。 　　C++ is the subject of controversy, especially in the game development community. There are

features of C++, like virtual functions, that add an extra layer of decision-making to function

calls, and critics are quick to point out that C++ programs can be larger and slower than C

counterparts. C++ advocates point out, however, that coding the equivalent of a virtual function

in C requires the same overhead. It's an on-going debate that's not likely to be decided soon.

　　我认为，C++的额外开支只是使用更好的语言的小付出。同样的争论发生在六十年代高级程序语言如COBOL

和FORTRAN开始取代汇编成为语言所选的时候。批评家正确的指出使用高级语言编写的程序天生就比手写的汇编

语言来得慢，而且必然如此。而高级语言支持者认为这么点小小的性能损失是值得的，因为COBOL和FORTRAN程

序更容易编写和维护。 　　In my opinion, the overhead of C++ is simply the price you pay for a better language. This

same debate went on in the 60's when high-level programming languages like COBOL and FORTRAN

started to displace hand-coded assembly as the language of choice. Critics correctly pointed out

that programs written in high-level languages were inherently slower than hand-tuned assembly and

always would be. High-level language advocates pointed out, however, that the slight performance

hit was worth it because COBOL and FORTRAN programs were much easier to write and maintain.

　　优点：组织大型程序时比C语言好得多。很好的支持面向对象机制。通用数据结构，如链表和可增长的阵列

组成的库减轻了由于处理低层细节的负担。 　　Advantages: Much better than C for organizing large programs. Supports the object-oriented

paradigm nicely. Libraries of common data structures, like linked lists and grow-able arrays, can

remove much of the burden of having to deal with low-level details.

　　缺点：非常大而复杂。与C语言一样存在语法滥用问题。比C慢。大多数编译器没有把整个语言正确的实现

。 　　Disadvantages: Extremely large and complicated. Like C, the syntax lends itself to abuse. Can

be slower than C. Not many compilers implement the entire language correctly.

　　移植性：比C语言好多了，但依然不是很乐观。因为它具有与C语言相同的缺点，大多数可移植性用户界面

库都使用C++对象实现。 　　Portability: Better than C, but still not great. While it shares the same disadvantage as C,

most of the portable user-interface libraries are implemented as collections of C++ objects.

　　使用C++编写的游戏：非常非常多。大多数的商业游戏是使用C或C++编写的。 　　Games Written in C++: Lots and lots. Almost all commercial games are written in C or C++.

　　资料：最新版的《The C++ Programming Language》非常好。作为教程，有两个阵营，一个假定你知道C，

另外一个假定你不知道。到目前为止，最好的C++教程是《Who's Afraid of C++》，如果你已经熟知C，那么试

一下《Teach Yourself C++》。 　　Resources: The latest edition of The C++ Programming Language is excellent. As for tutorials,

there are two camps, ones that assume you know C, and ones you don't. By far the best ground-up

C++ tutorials are Who's Afraid of C++ and Who's Afraid of More C++. If you already know C, try

Teach Yourself C++.

3、我该学习C++或是该从C开始（Should I learn C++, or should I start with C ） 　　我不喜欢这种说法，但它是继“我该使用哪门语言”之后最经常被问及的问题。很不幸，不存在标准答案

。你可以自学C并使用它来写程序，从而节省一大堆的时间，不过使用这种方法有两个弊端： 　　I thought this bore mentioning, as it's the second most commonly asked question next to

"which programming language should I use?"Unfortunately, the answer isn't black and white. You

could save a lot of time by just teaching yourself C and writing apps, but there are two

disadvantages to this approach. 你将错过那些面向对象的知识，因为它可能在你的游戏中使得数据建模更有效率的东西。 You're missing out on what will likely be a much more effective way of modeling the data in your

game. By not learning OO programming off the bat, you could be enforcing bad programming habits

that you'll have to un-learn later. Trust me on this one.

最大的商业游戏，包括第一人称射击游戏很多并没有使用C++。但是，这些程序的作者即使使用老的C的格式，

他们通常坚持使用面向对象编程技术。如果你只想学C，至少要自学OO（面向对象）编程技术。OO是仿真（游戏

）的完美方法，如果你不学习OO，你将不得不“辛苦”的工作。 Many of the biggest commercial games, including most first-person shooters, get by without C++.

The authors of these programs, however, always insist that they're using object-oriented

programming techniques even though they're using plain old C. If you want to just learn C, at

least teach yourself OO programming techniques. OO is the perfect methodology for simulations

(read: games), and you'll really be doing it "the hard way" if you push off learning OO.

4、汇编语言（Assembly） 　　显然，汇编是第一个计算机语言。汇编语言实际上是你计算机处理器实际运行的指令的命令形式表示法。

这意味着你将与处理器的底层打交道，比如寄存器和堆栈。如果你要找的是类英语且有相关的自我说明的语言

，这不是你想要的。 　　By default, assembly was the first computer language. Assembly language is actually a

command-based representation of the actual instructions that your computer's processor runs. That

means you will be dealing with the low-level details of your processor, like registers and

stacks. If you're looking for a language that's English-like and is relatively self-documenting,

this isn't it!

　　确切的说，任何你能在其他语言里做到的事情，汇编都能做，只是不那么简单 — 这是当然，就像说你既

可以开车到某个地方，也可以走路去，只是难易之分。话虽不错，但是新技术让东西变得更易于使用。 　　By definition, anything you can do in any other language, you can do in assembly, only not as

easily --of course, that's like saying that anywhere you can go in a car, you can go on foot,

only not as easily. While the statement might be true, the later technologies made things much

easier to use.

　　总的来说，汇编语言不会在游戏中单独应用。游戏使用汇编主要是使用它那些能提高性能的零零碎碎的部

分。比如说，毁灭战士整体使用C来编写，有几段绘图程序使用汇编。这些程序每秒钟要调用数千次，因此，尽

可能的简洁将有助于提高游戏的性能。而从C里调用汇编写的函数是相当简单的，因此同时使用两种语言不成问

题。 　　In general, assembly language is not used on its own for games. Games that use assembly

language use it in bits and pieces where it can improve performance. For example, DOOM is written

entirely in C with a couple of drawing routines hand-coded in assembly. They are the routines

that are called a few thousand times a second, so making the routine as tight as possible really

helped the performance of the game. It's fairly easy to write a function in assembly that is

call-able from C, so using both languages wasn't a problem.

　　特别注意：语言的名字叫“汇编”。把汇编语言翻译成真实的机器码的工具叫“汇编程序”。把这门语言

叫做“汇编程序”这种用词不当相当普遍，因此，请从这门语言的正确称呼作为起点出发。 　　Special Note: The name of the language is "assembly". The name of the tool that converts

assembly language into true machine code is called an "assembler". It's a common misnomer to call

the language "assembler", so start out on the right foot by calling the language by its proper

name.

　　优点：最小、最快的语言。汇编高手能编写出比任何其他语言能实现的快得多的程序。你将是利用处理器

最新功能的第一人，因为你能直接使用它们。 　　Advantages: Is, by definition, the smallest and fastest language. A talented assembly

programmer can write programs that are faster than anything that can be done in other languages.

You'll be the first person to be able to take advantage of the processor's latest new features,

because you can use them directly.

　　缺点：难学、语法晦涩、坚持效率，造成大量额外代码 — 不适于心脏虚弱者。 　　Disadvantages: Difficult to learn, cryptic syntax, tough to do efficiently, and it takes much

more code to get something done --not for the faint of heart!

　　移植性：接近零。因为这门语言是为一种单独的处理器设计的，根本没移植性可言。如果使用了某个特殊

处理器的扩展功能，你的代码甚至无法移植到其他同类型的处理器上（比如，AMD的3DNow指令是无法移植到其

它奔腾系列的处理器上的）。 　　Portability: Zilch. Since the language is designed for a single processor, it is not portable

by definition. If you use extensions specific to a particular brand of processor, your code isn't

even portable to other processors of the same type (for example, AMD 3DNOW instructions are not

portable to other Pentium-class processors).

　　使用汇编编写的游戏：我不知道有什么商业游戏是完全用汇编开发的。不过有些游戏使用汇编完成多数对

时间要求苛刻的部分。 　　Games Written in Assembly: I don't know of any commercial games that are written entirely in

assembly. Some games, however, have the most time-critical portions done in assembly.

　　资料：如果你正在找一门汇编语言的文档，你主要要找芯片的文档。网络上如Intel、AMD、Motorola等有

一些关于它们的处理器的资料。对于书籍而言，《Assembly Language: Step-By-Step》是很值得学习的。 　　Resources: When you're looking for documentation for an assembly language, you're basically

looking for the documentation for the chip. There is some online information at [Intel],

[AMD][Motorola] for their processors. As for books, [Assembly Language: Step-By-Step] is

well-reviewed.

5、Pascal语言 　　Pascal语言是由Nicolas Wirth在七十年代早期设计的，因为他对于FORTRAN和COBOL没有强制训练学生的结

构化编程感到很失望，“空心粉式代码”变成了规范，而当时的语言又不反对它。Pascal被设计来强行使用结

构化编程。最初的Pascal被严格设计成教学之用，最终，大量的拥护者促使它闯入了商业编程中。当Borland发

布IBM PC上的 Turbo Pascal时，Pascal辉煌一时。集成的编辑器，闪电般的编译器加上低廉的价格使之变得不

可抵抗，Pascal编程了为MS-DOS编写小程序的首选语言。 　　Pascal was designed by Nicolas Wirth in the early 70's, because he was dismayed to see that

FORTRAN and COBOL were not enforcing healthy structured programming disciplines in students.

"Spaghetti code" was becoming the norm, and the languages of the time weren't discouraging it.

Pascal was designed from the ground up to enforce structured programming practices. While the

original Pascal was designed strictly for teaching, it had enough advocates to eventually make

inroads into commercial programming. Pascal finally took the spotlight in a big way when Borland

released Turbo Pascal for the IBM PC. The integrated editor, lightning-fast compiler, and low

price were an irresistible combination, and Pascal became the preferred language for writing

small programs for MS-DOS.

　　然而时日不久，C编译器变得更快，并具有优秀的内置编辑器和调试器。Pascal在1990年Windows开始流行

时走到了尽头，Borland放弃了Pascal而把目光转向了为Windows 编写程序的C++。Turbo Pascal很快被人遗忘

。 　　The momentum, however, did not stay. C compilers became faster and got nice built-in editors

and debuggers. The almost-final nail in Pascal's coffin happened in the early 1990's when Windows

took over, and Borland ignored Pascal in favor of C++ for writing Windows applications. Turbo

Pascal was all but forgotten.

　　最后，在1996年，Borland发布了它的“Visual Basic杀手”— Delphi。它是一种快速的带华丽用户界面

的 Pascal编译器。由于不懈努力，它很快赢得了一大群爱好者。 　　Finally, in 1996, Borland released its "Visual Basic Killer", Delphi. Delphi was a fast

Pascal compiler coupled with a gorgeous user interface. Against all odds (and the Visual Basic

juggernaut), it gained a lot of fans.

　　基本上，Pascal比C简单。虽然语法类似，它缺乏很多C有的简洁操作符。这既是好事又是坏事。虽然很难

写出难以理解的“聪明”代码，它同时也使得一些低级操作，如位操作变得困难起来。 　　On the whole, Pascal is simpler than C. While the syntax is similar, it lacks a lot of the

shortcut operations that C has. This is a good thing and a bad thing. It's harder to write

inscrutable "clever" code, but it makes low-level operations like bit-manipulation more

difficult.

　　优点：易学、平台相关的运行（Dephi）非常好。 　　Advantages: Easy to learn. Platform-specific implementations (Delphi) are very nice.

　　缺点：“世界潮流”面向对象的Pascal继承者（Modula、Oberon）尚未成功。语言标准不被编译器开发者

认同。专利权。 　　Disadvantages: "World class" OO successors to Pascal (Modula, Oberon) have not been

successful. Language standards are not adhered to by compiler-makers. Proprietary.

　　移植性：很差。语言的功能由于平台的转变而转变，没有移植性工具包来处理平台相关的功能。 　　Portability: Dismal. The features of the language changes from platform to platform, and

there are no portability toolkits to handle platform-specific features.

　　使用Pascal编写的游戏：几个。DirectX的Delphi组件使得游戏场所变大了。 　　Games Written in Pascal: A couple. The DirectX components for Delphi have made the playing

field more level.

　　资料：查找跟Delphi有关的资料，请访问：Inprise Delphi page。 　　Resources: The find out about Delphi, check out the Inprise Delphi page.

6、Visual Basic 　　哈，BASIC。回到八十年代的石器时代，它是程序初学者的第一个语言。最初的BASIC形式，虽然易于学习

，却是可怕的无组织化，它义无返顾的使用了GOTO充斥的“空心粉式代码”。当回忆起BASIC的行号和GOSUB命

令，没有几个人能止住眼角的泪水。 　　Ahh, BASIC. Way back in the stone-age of the 80's, it was the first language for budding

programmers. The original incarnations of BASIC, while easy to learn, were horribly unstructured,

leading to the a rash of GOTO-laden "spaghetti-code". Not many people wipe away tears when

reminiscing about BASIC's line numbers and the GOSUB command.

　　快速前进到九十年代早期，虽然不是苹果公司所希望的巨人，HyperCard仍然是一个在Windows下无法比拟

的吸引人的小型编程环境。Windows下的HyperCard克隆品如ToolBook又慢又笨又昂贵。为了与HyperCard一决高

下，微软取得了一个小巧的名为Thunder编程环境的许可权，并把它作为Visual Basci 1.0发布，其用户界面在

当时非常具有新意。这门语言虽然还叫做Basic（不再是全部大写），但更加结构化了，行号也被去除。实际上

，这门语言与那些内置于TRS-80、Apple II及Atari里的旧的ROM BASIC相比，更像是带Basic风格动词的Pascal

。 　　Fast-forward to the early 1990's. While not the monster that Apple was hoping for, HyperCard

was a compelling little programming environment that had no equal under Windows. Windows-based

HyperCard clones like ToolBook were slow, clunky, and expensive. To finally compete with

HyperCard, Microsoft licensed a neat little programming environment named Thunder, releasing it

as Visual Basic 1.0. The user-interface was very innovative for the time. The language, while

still called Basic (and no longer all-caps), was much more structured. Line numbers were

mercy-killed. The language was, in fact, much closer to Pascal with Basic-style verbs than the

old ROM BASIC that was built into every TRS-80, Apple ][, and Atari.

　　经过六个版本，Visual Basic变得非常漂亮。用户界面发生了许多变化，但依然保留着“把代码关联到用

户界面”的主旨。这使得它在与即时编译结合时变成了一个快速原型的优异环境。 　　Six versions later, Visual Basic is pretty deluxe. The user-interface has made some changes,

but still retains its "attach bits of code to the user-interface" motif. This, in combination

with instantaneous compiling, makes it a terrific environment for fast prototyping.

　　优点：整洁的编辑环境。易学、即时编译导致简单、迅速的原型。大量可用的插件。虽然有第三方的

DirectX插件，DirectX 7已准备提供Visual Basic的支持。 　　Advantages: Neat IDE. Easy to learn. Instantaneous compiling makes for very fast and easy

prototyping. Lots and lots of add-ons available. While there are currently third-party DirectX

add-ons for Visual Basic, DirectX version 7 is going to include support for Visual Basic right

out of the box.

　　缺点：程序很大，而且运行时需要几个巨大的运行时动态连接库。虽然表单型和对话框型的程序很容易完

成，要编写好的图形程序却比较难。调用Windows的API程序非常笨拙，因为VB的数据结构没能很好的映射到C中

。有OO功能，但却不是完全的面向对象。专利权。 　　Disadvantages: Apps are large and require several large runtime DLL's to run. While form and

dialog-based apps are easy to make, writing good graphical apps is more difficult. Calling

Windows API functions is clunky, because VB data structures don't map nicely to C. Has OO

features, but is not fully object-oriented. Proprietary.

　　移植性：非常差。因为Visual Basic是微软的产品，你自然就被局限在他们实现它的平台上。也就是说，

你能得到的选择是：Windows，Windows或Widnows。当然，有一些工具能将VB程序转变成Java。 　　Portability: Worse than dismal. Since Visual Basic is owned by Microsoft, you're pretty-much

limited to whatever platforms they've ported it too. That means that you've got the choice of

Windows, Windows, or Windows. Note that there are, however, a couple of tools that help convert

VB apps to Java.

　　使用Visual Basic编写的游戏：一些。有很多使用VB编写的共享游戏，还有一些是商业性的。 　　Games Written in Visual Basic: A few. There are lots of shareware games done in VB, and a

couple of commercial offerings.

　　资料：微软的VB页面有一些信息。 　　Resources: The [Microsoft VB page].

7、Java 　　Java是由Sun最初设计用于嵌入程序的可移植性“小C++”。在网页上运行小程序的想法着实吸引了不少人

的目光，于是，这门语言迅速崛起。事实证明，Java不仅仅适于在网页上内嵌动画 — 它是一门极好的完全的

软件编程的小语言。“虚拟机”机制、垃圾回收以及没有指针等使它很容易实现不易崩溃且不会泄漏资源的可

靠程序。 　　Java was originally designed by Sun to be a portable "small C++" that could be used in

embedded applications. The idea of running little applications in a web-page really captured

people's imaginations, so the language caught on quickly. It turned out that Java wasn't just

suitable for embedding animated banners in web pages --it was a downright nifty little language

for application programming! The "virtual machine" nature, garbage collection and lack of

pointers made it easy to make bulletproof apps that didn't crash and had no resource leaks.

　　虽然不是C++的正式续篇，Java从C++ 中借用了大量的语法。它丢弃了很多C++的复杂功能，从而形成一门

紧凑而易学的语言。不像C++，Java强制面向对象编程，要在Java里写非面向对象的程序就像要在Pascal里写“

空心粉式代码”一样困难。 　　While not an official "sequel" to C++, Java borrows very heavily from C++ syntax. It dumps

many of the more difficult C++ features to reveal a rather compact and easy-to-learn language.

Unlike C++, Java enforces object-orientation with a heavy hand. Writing a non-OO app in Java is

as difficult as writing spaghetti-code in Pascal.

　　优点：二进制码可移植到其他平台。程序可以在网页中运行。内含的类库非常标准且极其健壮。自动分配

合垃圾回收避免程序中资源泄漏。网上数量巨大的代码例程。 　　Advantages: Binaries are portable to other platforms. Apps can run embedded in web pages. The

included class library is reasonably standardized and extremely robust. Automatic allocation and

garbage collection all but eliminates resource leaks in applications. Zillions of code examples

on the web.

　　缺点：使用一个“虚拟机”来运行可移植的字节码而非本地机器码，程序将比真正编译器慢。有很多技术

（例如“即时”编译器）很大的提高了Java的速度，不过速度永远比不过机器码方案。早期的功能，如AWT没经

过慎重考虑，虽然被正式废除，但为了保持向后兼容不得不保留。越高级的技术，造成处理低级的机器功能越

困难，Sun为这门语言增加新的“受祝福”功能的速度实在太慢。 　　Disadvantages: Uses a "virtual machine" to run portable byte-code rather than native machine

code, so apps are slower than true compilers. There are technologies (like "Just In Time"

compilers) that greatly improve the speed of Java, but the speed will likely always lag behind

true machine-code solutions. Early features like the Abstract Windowing Toolkit were not well

thought-out and, while officially abandoned, have to hang around for backward compatibility. Is

very high-level, which makes dealing with any low-level machine features very difficult. Sun is

pretty slow in adding new "blessed" features to the language.

　　移植性：最好的，但仍未达到它本应达到的水平。低级代码具有非常高的可移植性，但是，很多UI及新功

能在某些平台上不稳定。 　　Portability: The best of the lot, but still not what it should be. The low-level code is very

portable, but a lot of the UI and newer features are wobbly on some platforms.

　　使用Java编写的游戏：网页上有大量小的Applet，但仅有一些是商业性的。有几个商业游戏使用Java作为

内部脚本语言。 　　Games Written in Java: Lots of little applets in web pages, but only a couple of commercial

offerings. Several commercial games use Java as the internal script language.

　　资料：Sun的官方Java页面有一些好的信息。IBM也有一个非常好的Java页面。JavaLobby是一个关于Java新

闻的最好去处。 　　Resources: [Sun's official Java page] has some good info. IBM also has an excellent [Java

page]. The [JavaLobby] is the best place to go for news about Java.

8、创作工具 　　上面所提及的编程语言涵盖了大多数的商业游戏。但是也有一个例外，这个大游戏由于它的缺席而变得突

出。 　　All of the programming languages mentioned above cover pretty-much every commercial game out

there. There is one exception, but it's such a big one that it would be conspicuous by its

absence.

　　“神秘岛”。没错，卖得最好的商业游戏不是使用以上任何一门语言编的，虽然有人说“神秘岛”99%是使

用 3D建模工具制作的，其根本的编程逻辑是在HyperCard里完成的。 　　Yep, the best selling commercial game of all time wasn't written in any of the above

languages. While some would say that 99% of Myst was written using 3D modeling tools, the

underlying program logic was done in HyperCard.

　　多数创作工具有点像Visual Basic，只是它们工作在更高的层次上。大多数工具使用一些拖拉式的流程图

来模拟流程控制。很多内置解释的程序语言，但是这些语言都无法像上面所说的单独的语言那样健壮。 　　Most authoring tools are a bit like Visual Basic, only they work at a much higher level. Most

of the tools use some kind of click-and-drag flowchart motif to model control flow. Many contain

embedded interpreted programming languages, but these languages aren't nearly as robust as the

standalone languages mentioned above.

　　优点：快速原型 — 如果你的游戏符合工具制作的主旨，你或许能使你的游戏跑得比使用其他语言快。在

很多情况下，你可以创造一个不需要任何代码的简单游戏。使用插件程序，如Shockware及IconAuthor播放器，

你可以在网页上发布很多创作工具生成的程序。 　　Advantages: Fast prototyping --if your game fits the motif the tool's made for, you can

probably get your game running faster than any other language. In many cases, you can make a

rudimentary game without writing any code. You can broadcast many authored apps on web pages with

plug-ins like Shockwave and IconAuthor Player.

　　缺点：专利权，至于将增加什么功能，你将受到工具制造者的支配。你必须考虑这些工具是否能满足你游

戏的需要，因为有很多事情是那些创作工具无法完成的。某些工具会产生臃肿得可怕的程序。 　　Disadvantages: Proprietary, so you're at the mercy of the tool-maker as to what features will

be added. You've gotta really look at these tools to see if they'll do everything that your

game's gonna require, because there are things that authoring tools simply can't do. Some of

these tools produce frighteningly bloated apps.

　　移植性：因为创作工具是具有专利权的，你的移植性以他们提供的功能息息相关。有些系统，如Director

可以在几种平台上创作和运行，有些工具则在某一平台上创作，在多种平台上运行，还有的是仅能在单一平台

上创作和运行。 　　Portability: Since authoring tools are proprietary, your portability is limited to whatever

they offer. Some systems, like Director, can author and run on several platforms. Some tools can

author on one platform but play on several. Some are single-platform beasts.

　　使用创作工具编写的游戏：“神秘岛”和其他一些同类型的探险游戏。所有的Shockwave游戏都在网络上。 　　Games Written in Authoring Tools: Myst and a few other "exploration" games of the same genre.

All of the Shockwave games on the web.

　　资料：Director、HyperCard、SuperCard、IconAuthor、Authorware。

9、结论（Conclusion） 　　你可能希望得到一个关于“我该使用哪种语言”这个问题的更标准的结论。非常不幸，没有一个对所有应

用程序都最佳的解决方案。C适于快而小的程序，但不支持面向对象的编程。C++完全支持面向对象，但是非常

复杂。Visual Basic与Delphi易学，但不可移植且有专利权。Java有很多简洁的功能，但是慢。创作工具可以

以最快的速度产生你的程序，但是仅对某一些类型的程序起作用。最好的方法是决定你要写什么样的游戏，并

选择对你的游戏支持最好的语言。“试用三十天”的做法成为工业标准是件好事情。 　　You probably were hoping for a more cut-n-dry conclusion to the "what programming language do

I use" dilemma. Unfortunately, there's no solution that's optimal for all applications. C is

suited for fast and small applications, but doesn't support OO programming well. C++ has very

complete OO support, but is frighteningly complicated. Visual Basic and Delphi are easy to learn,

but are non-portable and proprietary. Java has a lot of neat features, but is slow. Authoring

tools can get your app working quickest, but are only useful for a narrow range of applications.

It might just be best for you to figure out what kind of game you're writing and pick the

language that would best support your game. It's a good thing that the "try it free for 30 days"

offer has become the industry norm :-)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 作者简介 　　John Hattan是位于德克萨斯州的Watauga里最大的软件公司 — Code Zone的主要负责人。如果你对他的文

章有什么看法，请写信给他。

将各种语言分析的相当透彻 虽然作者并没有告诉我们选择哪种工具好 但是我们完全可以根据他的介绍和自己的喜好来选择使用哪种语言

顶